Ethics Case Studies in Biodesign

Case 10 - Third World Considerations

You are developing a tool used in hip replacement. A disposable device is the best business model in the U.S.A. You know doctors in developing countries are likely to reuse the device against company recommendations. Of materials A & B, A is less expensive but B will not weaken when exposed to the heat and pressure of autoclave sterilization.

• Which material do you choose?
• Should you sell the device for more or less to doctors in countries that will reuse the device?